Interpreting Test Scores in Toddlers and Preschoolers – “Teach Me To Talk with Laura and Kate” on Thursday, February 12, 2009

Join Kate and me this week for Teach Me To Talk with Laura and Kate on Thursday, February 12 at 6:00 pm Eastern time.

This week we’re going to discuss how to interpret test scores from speech-language evaluations and other standardized and criterion-referenced developmental assessments. This may not be the most interesting topic we’ve ever covered, but I routinely get questions about this on the website, in e-mails, and from parents I work with wondering exactly what it all means.

If you have general questions about results of your child’s testing, we’d love to hear from you! Please call us with your questions or comments. Our call-in number is 1-718-766-4332. We’d love to hear from you!

You can listen live by clicking this icon. Listen to Teach Me To Talk with Laura and Kate on internet talk radio

If you can’t join us live, you can always listen later anytime using the blogtalkradio icon in the right hand column or on the home page.

Our show is also available for FREE download on itunes. Visit the itunes store and search “Teach Me to Talk with Laura and Kate.” For you itunes novices, choose subscribe, and the show will download so you can listen later with your ipod.

Hope you’ll join us! Laura

m4s0n501

Comments

  1. Lorelei says

    Thank you for providing such a valuable resource. I wonder if you can address something we were told by an Early Intervention worker. We told her that we wanted to take our son to a private speech pathologist to get a second opinion, because we were not confident about the first evaluation he received. Our primary concern with the original evaluation was that we think he seems to have some sort of a physical problem (like apraxia or something similar), but the first pathologist apparently did not think so. The county worker informed us that we cannot have a second evaluation done by anyone until 6 months have gone by, or it’s not “valid.” What?? She is telling us that there is some sort of rule among speech pathologists that works to prevent parents from receiving a second opinion? Do you know what she is talking about and can you explain? I am wondering now if I am going to have to hide the fact of the first evaluation in order to get a second one? I am not good at dissembling so I am uncomfortable at the prospect. However, I am prepared to do whatever is required in order to get my son a good evaluation.

  2. Maria says

    Dear Laura and Kate,

    Thank you so much for doing this show. My 23-month-old just “barely qualified” for speech and we had decided to wait and see before going forward because she scored so high in all of the other areas. Ten minutes into your show, I paused it and called the evaluator back to tell her we changed our minds! By the end of the show, I was just stunned (and a little terrified). The evaluator really made it sound like “barely qualified” meant that she was just a little behind. It was really hard to hear but needed to be said.

    Thanks again for all of your work in putting together this wonderful resource.

  3. Laura says

    Maria – Glad the information was helpful in assisting you to make good decisions for your daughter. 23 months is a GREAT age to start therapy, and since she has so many strengths in other areas, I hope therapy is a “jump start” for her and that she’s catches up quickly. Let us know how she does! Laura

  4. Laura says

    Lorelei – There is no “rule” among SLPs about evals not being “valid” if done within 6 months of each other. The rule may be that your state program doesn’t pay for or allow another assessment for 6 months, but if you’re doing this privately and are not using the same payor system for both (say your insurance), you should be fine. Seeking a 2nd opinion is even pretty standard for insurance companies, so I don’t even think that would be a problem unless your policy prohibits this. I have heard that some state early intervention programs dissallow services thru their programs if a child is being seen thru another program, so this could be the reason too, but these are all related to PAYMENT issues, not anything resembling “validity.” If your gut tells you to get another opinion, then I’d do it, regardless of who I had to tell/not tell to make it happen. Laura

  5. Lorelei says

    Thanks so much for the reply, I really appreciate your help. It’s very nice of you to take the time to help out a total stranger like me! I suspected as much, but then I thought, what do I know?

  6. Carey says

    Hi: I just listened to your talk on the the “barely eligible” issue. Does this apply to the Michigan test as well? Also, in my state, children must have a 30 percent delay in one developmental area to qualify. How does that effect the interpretation of barely eligible scores?Thanks so much for your very informative website and talks.

  7. Laura says

    Carey – I don’t know the Michigan regulations. My advice is to talk to the team who evaluated your child and scour the report and specific test results for answers. Laura

  8. teresa says

    Laura,

    My daughter is almost 4 and too old for our county based Early Intervention program, so I have been trying to get the school district to take her on. Long story short, her scores always show to be within normal range even though I feel like there is a big language based problem going on. We recently had her tested with a private slp again. She used the CELF Preshool 2. In pretty much showed normal scores except in one area. Hooray, I am not crazy!

    Here’s a quick preview of her scores:
    Average Range 86-114

    core language 92
    receptive 94
    Expressive 87
    language content 100
    language structure 80*

    Subtest areas that she fell out of average range on – range 7-13

    word structure 5
    concepts and following directions 7
    recalling sentences 6

    additionally she had a huge discrepancy in her LCI and LSI scores: language content score 100, structure index 80 making a difference of 20 and a Prevalence of 2.4%

    The manual stated anything under 5% was HIGHLY unusal.

    What can you tell me about such a low prevalence and do you have any suggestions as to activities that would target language structure.

    Thanks. You are a gift.

  9. Laura says

    Teresa – This is a complicated question! You likely are going to have to have her seen by a private SLP since she is scoring in the normal range overall. I don’t use the CELF, so I can’t really comment on the specifics of that test other than to say that her scores do not fit a normal pattern of delay. You’re going to need someone to really help you unravel this mystery, and most of the time, school SLPs are not going to be the one to do that since they don’t have time with their busy caseloads. If at all possible, I’d recommend that you ask many people for referrals to private SLPs and when you start hearing the same name over and over, take her to that person. Good luck!! Laura

  10. Misty says

    Hello Laura,
    I am unable to listen to your program because I have an ancient computer!
    Can you tell me why a child (2.9 year old female) may score higher on the expressive portion of the Pls-4 than the receptive portion. No signs of autism…Family is speaking in 2 different languages…
    Thanks!
    Misty

  11. Laura says

    Hi Misty. It perhaps could be an early indication of an auditory processing. How are her pragmatic skills? Is she “using” the words she knows? Sometimes the PLS-4 seems to artificially inflate expressive skills. Take a hard look at the milestones and be sure you’re not giving her credit for things she’s truly not mastered in her daily life. Laura

  12. Lynn says

    So when are you planning to be on TV again? And if so what time and what channel will it be on? i’m new to this ..I have speech and over all development coming in to work with my child ..And i need all the help I can get..thank Lynn

  13. Laura says

    Lynn – I’m not on TV. My show is a podcast which is more like a radio show. You can listen to any episode from here on the website. Scroll up and look in the right column for the blue square that says “blogtalkradio.” Click on the # and you can listen to the show from your computer. If you have an iPod, you can download the show from iTunes and listen from it. Laura

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.