A Little Frustration CAN Go A Long Way …..Using Sabotage And Withholding Effectively to Entice Your Toddler To Talk

As a parent, it’s heartbreaking to see your child suffer when he’s frustrated. This seems to be especially true when that frustration revolves around communication, or the lack of it.

However, as an SLP, I sometimes want a child to be frustrated. I often purposefully set up situations like this during therapy sessions because I think it might make a kid try a little harder. Actually I know it makes lots of children try harder. Sometimes the extra emotional burst that a child feels when he’s a little frustrated is just enough to propel him over a hurdle he’s needed to conquer for a long time.

I read this quote on a parenting message board a few weeks ago. I loved it so much that I copied it, and I’d like to share it here –

” I think it is a truth for humankind that FRUSTRATION helps the learning process and builds determination, but FAILURE does not. In general, of course. Difficulty can build character and discipline and commitment to one’s goal, but FAILURE repeated over and over is defeating, and especially for children, can be damaging to one’s self-concept and self-efficacy…..I try to keep that in mind when Sam has frustration as well. I want him to learn to strive, not learn to fail.”

(By the way, I have tried and failed to find the specific post I copied this from so that I could attribute it to the insightful mom who wrote such eloquent words. If you know her or ARE her, please send me a comment so that I can give you proper credit for your wonderful advice!)

So after contemplating this quote for the last few weeks, I wanted to share with you how I’ve learned to set up situations that may cause a little communication FRUSTRATION, but not result in communication FAILURE.

Setting up situations so that a child is more likely to communicate is commonly referred to in the speech-language and early intervention literature as “environmental sabotage.” Using environmental sabotage is not a new technique to speech therapy. The idea has been around since I went to school back in the ’80’s. My very old professor talked about it like she’d used it forever. Back then she called it, “Communication Temptations.” I probably prefer that term to “sabotage” since some parents tend to interpret the word negatively and then carry it out in the same mean-spirited way.

Actually, I know that I was guilty of this a time or two when I first started seeing children professionally. I remember one cute little blonde-headed boy in particular. I would hold out for a word waaaaaaay beyond what I would dream of doing now. He did cross the divide between frustration and failure on more than one occasion, and for that I am now deeply sorry. I was sorry even then, and so much so that I would walk back to my car on the verge of tears myself thinking, “There’s got to be a better way.” It did make me start to find things to do to “sabotage” in a more kid- friendly way.

Besides, what’s the purpose of using a technique if the end result is a two-year-old who’s rolling around on the floor kicking and screaming? In my opinion, no child learns anything at that point, except for maybe, “That lady is mean, and I don’t ever want to play with her again!”

If you’ve read anything I’ve ever written, you already know that I will move heaven and earth to make a connection with a kid. In my opinion, and many “experts,” you must first establish a relationship with a child so that you build a foundation of social connectedness. All communication, all the back-and-forth and give-and-take that we use in conversation is built upon the idea, “I’m important. You’re important.” You talk – I talk. I ask – you answer. I want to get to know and like you – I want you to get to know me and like me.

Withholding and sabotaging a kid past the point of him knowing you and liking you defeats this purpose. BUT sabotage can be done in a fun, animated, teasingly way so that a child feels like, “She gets me. She knows I can do this.”

Basic explanations for withholding and sabotage are written below. In my mind these are very similar, but for you purists, here are definitions.

Withholding is purposefully keeping something away from a child until he says the word (or signs or gestures) to request the object. I always use a model (by saying or signing what I want the kid to say) during withholding.

Sabotaging is setting up situations or problems that a child has to solve so that he can get what he wants. I don’t give a model during sabotage until I know the child can’t say what he needs to say in order to get what he wants.

For example, I playfully guard a plastic, see-through bag full of snacks and teasingly say, “What do you want?”

Or I set up a race track but don’t provide race cars and then act surprised (and stupid) until a child asks for “Cars.”

At home you might put a child in a bathtub and not run the water yet to see if he will ask for it.

Or you might give him an empty cup.

Or give everyone else but him a cookie.

You might put one sock and one shoe on him and then proceed to go outside.

You might stand in front of him and visibly eat his favorite Skittles.

Get the idea? Set up obvious situations so that it is darn near impossible for him NOT to ask for something.

These are pretty effective techniques, but I have seen well-meaning parents (and professionals) use them in the wrong ways. For example, a father standing over a screaming child withholding his cup telling him, “You can’t have it until you say it,” when the child hasn’t uttered any vocalization that comes close to the word milk in his whole life. A therapist who digs in her heels and thinks, “He’s got to learn,” as she watches a sobbing toddler run repeatedly to his mother for consolation because he’s not yet said the target word is another ineffective example.

Here are the basics for effectively and correctly using these techniques with children –

1.  Approach the situation with a FUN attitude, not, “I-am-going-to-make-you-ask-for-this-or-else!”

Purposefully make yourself look and sound FUN and HAPPY before, during, and after you’re using this technique. If you feel yourself crossing over the line to not-fun, not-happy, and plain old mean, stop the game immediately and just give the kid what he wants.

2. Hold out for your intended word, sign, or gesture only 3-5 times.

This is according to research done by the National Institutes of Health. (I wish I could remember the name and year of the study, but I don’t.  Sorry to those of you who are perfectionists and “Says Who?” types.) According to this information, no learning takes place after this point. This may be true even earlier for a kid who is borderline hysterical after just one “try.” If the child you are trying to entice to communicate is DONE, then you need to be done too.

3. If the child gives you a word or “try” that’s acceptable, but not perfect, reward the effort.

Effort counts, especially for late talking toddlers. When you reward the effort, he’s going to continue to try again. Remember practice makes perfect. Sometimes I will give the child the object even if he uses an all-purpose word like “more” or “please” even when I’ve intended for him to say another word. I’d rather him WANT to try again than to risk alienating him. But if he can handle it, I hold out for the specific word, at least for a little while longer.

4. Don’t overuse sabotage so that he feels like he shouldn’t even try.

If you find your child walking away or giving up, you’re not being flexible enough or starting at a place when he can succeed. This would be the failure part. Analyze what you’re sabotaging and how often you’re using this technique. I have some children on my caseload right now that I can “sabotage” or “withhold” with for a whole hour-long session, and they’re fine and happy. I have some that I might try once or twice in a session. I have a few that I won’t use this with for a very long time because of temperament issues (It makes them too darn mad!) and/or cognitive issues (They don’t get what I’m doing).

FYI – Kids who NEVER initiate and seek out anyone to help them with tasks may not understand this concept for a while. This would be the kid who radar-locks his vision on the toy or snack you’re holding rather than glancing up at your face for even a moment. You might as well not be in the room as far as he’s concerned. He hasn’t learned the JOINT part of joint-attention yet. If you’re trying this with a kid who is pretty self-absorbed, you may want to measure his progress and “reward” him for even noticing that you are part of the game. When I withhold a treasured object from a kid like this and he makes eye contact for a millisecond, I give him what he wants.

5. Use true withholding and sabotage only for words or signs kids can already say or do on their own.

If you’ve never heard your child ask for “milk,” stick to modeling it and waiting for him to imitate you, even while he’s drinking the milk, rather than withholding until he does say it. Holding out for a brand new word without a model and with no hope of them getting it is just plain mean. Save this technique to help your child spontaneously ask for something with a word he’s been imitating or using for a while.

Bottom line –

Model to get kids to imitate new words.

Withhold to make those easily imitated words more spontaneous.

Sabotage to work on initiating communication.

Good luck!!

Laura

Read more about ways to help a child learn to initiate in Let’s Talk About Talking. There’s a whole chapter full of great ideas!

Posted in

Laura

1 Comment

  1. Yaneli on March 16, 2017 at 2:48 pm

    Hi my daughter’s name is serenity, she’s 2 years old and I believe she’s an FYI child. She’s taking Speech therapy and I would like to make it easier on her and everyone else if she could just communicate a little better. Every time we ask her what something is ( she already knows the word) she gets stubborn and cries and gets mad and runs away. We ask her if she can tell us the color of the ball (she knows the colors because she says them when we’re at home alone, but she gets stubborn when the Speech Therapist is here and will just act up) is there anything I can do that I can make her talk better? Thank You!

Leave a Comment





Sign Up for your Free eBook

FREE-EBOOK
Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.

Subscribe to the Podcast in iTunes

Browse Products

Featured Product

Recent Posts

Teach Me To Talk Testimonials

Happy Therapists, Teachers, Parents & Children

"I just received Teach Me to Play With You, and it is ALREADY WORKING! WOW!

Girl…my son is 3 years old, and he NEVER asks for something using words. We were playing “Get Your Belly” (from Teach Me to Play WITH You), and after several times, he laughed and screamed "BEWIEEE!!!"  It was a hoot. And I can't believe he said it! I have played with him like this before, but this time I took your advice and acted CRAZY!! I will act like a total lunatic if it will get him to talk to me!  Now I can give him "the look" from across the room, and he will say it. That manual is so amazingly practical, and it is a GODSEND right now! Thank you SO MUCH!”

"I wanted to send you a quick email to say thank you. I started watching your videos/podcasts about 4 months ago. My son has gone from losing words he previously used, only having about 7 words at his 2 year check up in August (assessed at a blended 10 month language level) -- to now having so many words, increased social engagement, following commands, spontaneously requesting things, and naming letters & numbers (not in order) as well as colors. We had our monthly meeting with our SLP through the state infants & toddlers program and it felt like we were just bragging the whole time, but I knew in the back of my head it was because I have been using strategies you taught me.

We still have so much work to do with our sweet boy, but I know in my heart he would not have succeeded without the education you provided. I will continue to read your emails & watch videos as we go along this journey and face challenges, but credit is due to you, Laura.

Thank you so much, endlessly."

KATIE

"I just want to tell how fortunate I feel to have found your website and you!! I became a special instructor in EI almost a year ago and I started with hardly any applicable training. I felt so lost and confused as how to help the kids I work with learn how to use words and play. Honestly, I didn't even understand the importance of play, although I always played with my kids. But, once I started to watch your podcasts and get some of your manuals I felt a weight had been lifted off my shoulders and that I could finally teach these kids and their families something of value from a real therapist and based on research!. Thank you so much for seeing the need to help other EI service providers and providing a forum to share your knowledge and years of valuable experience. I'm sure you get a lot of these emails every week if not every day, but I wanted to make I could add to those notes of gratitude!! THANK YOU again!!"

SS

"Just wanted to say a HUGE thank you for these emails and your books, I have them all and they have seriously saved and improved my sessions with my kiddos. Huge thank you."

REBECCA

"I was very frustrated with how speech therapy was going for my child. I would take him and drop him off and not hear much of anything from his therapist and teachers other than, "He had a good (or a bad!) day." Your materials were invaluable for us because I learned how to work with him on his speech. I learned how to teach him to talk and play. I learned how to pay attention to his cues and work with him to teach him to communicate. Without it, I have no doubt he still wouldn’t talk."

BRITNEY

"Hi! I just wanted to say (from an SLT perspective) how incredibly useful I am finding absolutely all of your articles, blogs and resources - I only discovered your site last month and have just received all your books which I feel I am learning more than on my entire university training course!! But also the way in which you give specific, realistic, fun, encouraging ideas for working with parents is really just fantastic, I only wish I have your site sooner! Thanks so much from the UK! Kind regards."

HANNAH

"I just wanted to reach out to say thank you for making things a little easier to manage for me this year. I made the transition from school SLP to private therapist about a year ago. While the change was welcome, it was a lot, and I was just getting my footing in the clinic when I began teletherapy full time. Your website has been a huge lifeline in helping me work with late talkers and coach their parents in an accessible but effective way, even remotely. I look forward to getting your emails each week. I am floored by the amount of valuable, free information that your website provides, and I’m looking forward to investing in your workbooks soon. A sincere thank you for all you do!"

ALLISON

"You are an inspiration! I am truly grateful for the way you put into words and writing how to do what we do as SLPs. At this time in my 13 years of practicing, I find your encouragement keeps me going. As a single mom, I find it a stretch to buy materials these days and I am so thankful for the freebies you so generously share that help me teach my families. I don’t have much time to put together lists or quick references for parents!! Much gratitude!!"

ANDREA